ERV vs HRV for a Dry Colorado House: What the Federal Guides Say

A tight house needs fresh air brought in on purpose. Two machines do that while recovering heat from the air going out: the heat recovery ventilator (HRV) and the energy recovery ventilator (ERV). The question homeowners ask is which one, and the answer turns on one thing: moisture.

In a humid climate the job is keeping summer moisture out. A dry winter house has the opposite worry. This post uses U.S. Department of Energy and Building America Solution Center guidance (the Building America Solution Center, or BASC, is run by Pacific Northwest National Laboratory for DOE) to explain the difference, what the guides say about dry and cold climates, and which parts of the decision belong to a professional.

What is the difference between an ERV and an HRV?

An HRV moves heat between the outgoing and incoming air; an ERV moves heat and some moisture. DOE’s Building Science Education page says both “include a heat exchanger, one or more fans to push air through the machine, and controls,” and that ERVs “transfer a certain amount of water vapor; this helps the humidity inside the home stay more constant.”

BASC’s guide for existing homes puts it in technical terms: “ERVs transfer moisture (latent heat) as well as temperature (sensible heat),” while “HRVs transfer sensible heat only; they do not transfer moisture.”

Both are balanced systems. BASC’s HRV/ERV checklist describes a unit that brings in fresh air and “exhausts an equal amount of stale air from the home, ensuring balanced pressures throughout the home.” Inside the core, the two air streams pass each other without mixing, and heat (plus moisture, for an ERV) crosses from one to the other.

HRV ERV
What crosses the core Heat only (“sensible heat”) Heat and some moisture (“latent heat” too)
Effect on indoor humidity Exhausts indoor moisture with the stale air Returns part of the moisture to the incoming air
Fans, controls, balanced flow Yes Yes
BASC’s framing “Recommended for cold-dry climates” (code brief) Can “help retain moisture” in dry winter homes (existing-homes guide)

ERV or HRV: what decides the choice

Neither is better everywhere. BASC says plainly: “There is not a hard-and-fast rule about which type of system is more appropriate.” The choice depends on whether the house needs to hold on to indoor moisture or get rid of it, which in turn depends on climate, how airtight the house is and how much moisture the people inside produce.

BASC’s existing-homes guide offers one simple test for humid places: “Is it usually too humid outdoors? If so, an ERV may be a better choice.” It adds that “the ERV/HRV question is easiest to answer in hot, humid climates,” where an ERV can “help reduce moisture introduced by a ventilation system.”

A dry climate flips the question. Outdoor air is not the moisture problem; dry indoor air in winter may be. That is where the guides split their answer into two cases.

ERV vs HRV in a dry, cold climate

BASC gives two answers for cold climates, and which one applies depends on the house. For older homes where winter air is too dry, it says an ERV “can help retain moisture within the home and potentially improve comfort.” For very airtight homes with high indoor moisture, it points to an HRV instead, to bring humidity down.

The first case, in BASC’s words: “In many older homes in colder climates, indoor air during the winter is often uncomfortably dry,” and “an ERV can help retain moisture within the home and potentially improve comfort.”

The second case is the opposite house: very airtight, with a lot of moisture from cooking, showers and occupants. There, BASC’s guide suggests an HRV, because an HRV sends indoor moisture out with the exhaust air rather than handing it back.

BASC’s code compliance brief on colder climates takes a firmer line: “HRVs are recommended for cold-dry climates.” It adds that HRVs “are most cost effective in climates with extreme winters where fuel costs are high.” That brief is about code compliance, not about indoor comfort in a particular house, so read it alongside the existing-homes guidance rather than instead of it.

Your house in winter What BASC points to
Older, leakier house; indoor air “uncomfortably dry” ERV, to “help retain moisture”
Very airtight house; windows fog, high moisture from occupants HRV, to exhaust moisture
Code compliance in cold-dry climates HRV (“recommended for cold-dry climates”)

What an ERV will not do

An ERV does not add moisture from nowhere. BASC’s multifamily guide says “ERVs do not make a space drier or more humid than it already is,” and that they “simply help maintain the existing humidity level within the building enclosure.”

The existing-homes guide adds a nuance: “running an ERV will increase the amount of humidity in the home, but the humidity increase will be less than if a different ventilation strategy was used.” In a dry house, that retained moisture is the point. In a damp, tight house, it is the reason to choose an HRV.

The same multifamily guide warns that “in cold climates excessive dryness may occur” at recommended ventilation rates, “thus requiring humidification.” So even an ERV may not keep a very dry house comfortable on its own.

How to tell which house you have

BASC’s cold-weather humidity guide gives a target and a warning sign. “The ideal relative humidity in homes is between 35% and 50%,” it says, and “visible condensation or frost on windows or cold wall surfaces is an obvious sign of high humidity levels in the home.”

A house with fogged windows and frost on the glass is the moisture-heavy case. A house where the air feels dry and the windows stay clear is closer to the dry case. A humidity reading is a better guide than a feeling, and the indoor air quality testing guide covers what home monitors can and cannot measure.

Moisture, maintenance and fan power

The disadvantages BASC names are about moisture, maintenance and electricity. An ERV adds back some humidity, which a damp, airtight house does not need. BASC says “maintenance requirements of HRVs and ERVs are often more rigorous than for other ventilation systems,” and that in milder climates “the electricity costs can actually be greater than the thermal energy savings.”

Those points apply to HRVs as well. On power, BASC says “power consumption can vary widely, from below 30 Watts to above 200 Watts.” A fan that runs continuously adds up over a year, so the rated wattage matters when comparing models.

On ratings, BASC’s existing-homes guide suggests looking for “ASEF values above 80%” for heat recovery in cold weather, with the best systems above 90%, and for an ERV, “TRE values above 50%.” These ratings are on the equipment specification; a professional can compare them across models.

What does an ERV or HRV cost?

BASC gives cost ranges and is careful to date them. “Until recently, costs for core hardware ranged from approximately $400 to $2,000,” it says, with higher-end European units at “$3,000 to $5,000.” For installation, “some contractors have quoted installation costs of $1,000 to $1,500” where the space is fully accessible.

It also warns that “rules-of-thumb fail with more complex installations” that involve opening walls, ceilings or floors. These are BASC’s figures, not a quote for any particular house, and a condensate drain adds to the bill: “The need for a condensate drain and/or pump adds cost.”

Does an ERV need a drain line?

It depends on the unit. BASC’s existing-homes guide says to “install condensate drains as required by the manufacturers.” The manufacturer’s installation manual for the specific model is the document that answers this. A drain or condensate pump is plumbing work, part of the installation, and belongs to the installer.

Running an ERV in summer

BASC’s existing-homes guide says “especially in mixed climates, there are many situations where an ERV may be more beneficial during the cooling season.” In summer the core cools the incoming air with the cooler exhaust air, and an ERV also limits the moisture brought in. Whether to run it continuously or on a schedule is a controls question for the installer.

ERVs and dehumidifiers

In humid climates, possibly. BASC says “supplemental dehumidification is often necessary for dwellings in humid climates, e.g., IECC Climate Zones 1A, 2A, and 3A.” Its cold-weather guide also lists “provide supplemental dehumidification, if needed” where condensation persists. In a dry house the question reverses: BASC’s multifamily guide says cold-climate dryness may require humidification, and humidifiers need care. It warns that humidifiers “can be significant contaminant sources if distilled water is not used.”

Sizing an ERV for a 2,000 sq ft house

BASC’s balanced HRV/ERV checklist sets target ventilation rates by house size for continuous operation: “50 cfm for up to 1,500 ft², 70 cfm for 1,501 to 2,500 ft², and 100 cfm over 2,500 ft².” By that table, a 2,000 square foot house falls in the 70 cfm band.

That number is the airflow target, not the unit choice. The checklist also says “appropriate ventilation equipment shall be selected based on the target ventilation rate and the climate,” and that the delivered rate “shall be measured using a flow hood, flow grid, or anemometer.” Sizing, ducting, balancing and that measurement are professional work. BASC says “installation should be done by a qualified professional,” and that new systems “should be commissioned by a trained HVAC technician or energy rater to verify performance.”

BASC’s guide also points to ASHRAE Standard 62.2, which “provides minimum requirements for adequate home ventilation.”

Where should the intake and exhaust go?

Hood placement is a design decision made at installation. BASC says the intake “should be well above the ground and snow level, away from garages or parking areas,” and its checklist says the exhaust outlet is “at least 10 feet from any air inlet.” “Exhaust ducts should always terminate outdoors—never in an attic, basement, or crawlspace,” the guide adds.

Moving a hood or rerouting a duct means cutting into the house and is not a homeowner job. What a homeowner can do is keep what is already there clear.

What can a homeowner do?

BASC’s checklist says the installer should review with the homeowner “how and when to change filter” and “how and when to clean the intake screen.” It also requires that “the filter shall be installed to be easily accessible by occupants.” The homeowner part is four steps: the filter, the clearances, the thermostat and the carbon monoxide alarm.

  • Filter. BASC’s checklist calls for outdoor air to be “filtered with a MERV 11 filter or higher.” Follow the manufacturer’s schedule for checking and changing it. BASC notes that “many systems require periodic cleaning and/or replacement of heat exchange media, filters, and other parts”; the core itself is serviced as the manual directs.
  • Clearances. BASC says “outdoor air inlets should be checked periodically to make sure they are free from debris,” and intakes are “equipped with screens to keep out insects and debris.” Keep snow, leaves and stored items away from both outdoor hoods.
  • Thermostat. The ventilator does not replace the heating system. Confirm the heating and cooling still respond at the thermostat after any work on the ventilation system.
  • CO alarm. A balanced ventilator is not a carbon monoxide safeguard. Keep a working carbon monoxide alarm; if it sounds, leave the building and call 911 from outside. What to do when the alarm goes off covers the next steps.

Anything past those four, including opening the unit beyond the filter door, the condensate drain, wiring, ducting and balancing, is work for a heating and cooling professional. Moisture problems inside ducts, where a ventilator is tied into the system, are covered in the guide to mold in air ducts.

So, ERV or HRV for a dry house?

For an older house where winter air is “uncomfortably dry,” BASC says an ERV “can help retain moisture.” For a very airtight house with high indoor moisture, it points to an HRV. BASC’s code brief recommends HRVs for cold-dry climates. A humidity reading tells you which house you live in; a professional confirms the design.

Ventilation is one part of indoor air. Filtration is another, and the whole-house air purifier guide compares the options. For how ventilation fits with heating, insulation and air sealing, the year-round Boulder home systems guide maps the whole house.

For filtration and the equipment side of indoor air, Boulder HVAC Pros offers air filtration in Boulder, serving Boulder and the surrounding area. Call (720) 764-0399.

Frequently asked questions

Is an ERV better than an HRV?

Not universally. BASC says “there is not a hard-and-fast rule about which type of system is more appropriate.” An ERV returns some moisture to the house; an HRV exhausts it. The right one depends on climate and on whether the house is too dry or too damp.

What are the disadvantages of ERV?

An ERV adds back some humidity, which a damp, airtight house does not need. BASC also says HRV and ERV maintenance is “often more rigorous than for other ventilation systems,” and that in milder climates electricity costs can exceed the energy savings.

What size ERV for a 2000 sq ft house?

BASC’s checklist sets a continuous ventilation target of 70 cfm for 1,501 to 2,500 square feet. Unit selection, ducting and airflow measurement are done by the installer.

Do I need a dehumidifier if I have an ERV?

In humid climates, BASC says supplemental dehumidification “is often necessary.” In a cold, dry climate the issue can be the reverse: BASC says excessive dryness may occur, requiring humidification.

Should you run an ERV in the summer?

BASC says an ERV may be “more beneficial during the cooling season” in mixed climates. How it runs is set in the controls at installation.

Last verified: October 16, 2026.